Artificial intelligence is changing nearly every aspect of our world. But what does that mean for pastors, churches, and followers of Jesus? Should pastors be using ChatGPT to prepare sermons? Can AI help people grow in their faith? And at what point does technology stop being a helpful tool and start becoming a dangerous substitute for human relationships?
In this episode of the Red Letter Disciple Podcast, Zach Zehnder welcomes Pastor Rob Bailey, a church planter and pastor of South Lake Church in League City, Texas, for a practical and thought-provoking conversation about the opportunities and dangers of artificial intelligence in ministry.
Rob has spent the past several years experimenting with AI tools and helping other Lutheran pastors understand their potential. He also helped Zach analyze the 2026 State of the LCMS Survey, transforming more than 3,000 responses into accessible reports and an interactive website where people can explore the results themselves.
Together, Zach and Rob discuss how AI can make ministry more effective without replacing the responsibilities that belong to pastors and church leaders.
Rob shares how he uses AI to organize theological resources, build extensive sermon preparation materials, study Scripture, and create interactive discipleship tools. He explains how artificial intelligence can help pastors spend less time searching for information and more time studying, praying, and preparing to communicate God’s Word.
But the conversation doesn’t stop with the benefits.
Zach and Rob wrestle with some of the most important questions surrounding AI and the church today. What happens when pastors allow AI to do their thinking? How can churches protect sensitive information? What are the dangers of AI-generated theological answers? And what happens to genuine human relationships when people begin turning to artificial intelligence for companionship?
They also explore how AI could reshape the job market, particularly for young adults, and why churches need to prepare to minister to people navigating these changes.
Throughout the conversation, one conviction becomes clear: AI should serve the mission of the church, not replace the people called to carry it out.
Whether you’re a pastor, ministry leader, teacher, parent, or simply someone trying to follow Jesus faithfully in an increasingly digital world, this episode offers practical insights and important questions worth considering.
Today’s episode is brought to you by Reignite Conference.
Bring your team to RE:IGNITE 2027. Three days to grow your team’s leadership, communication, worship, and ministry strategy together. Hear main-stage speakers Greg Griffith (Lead Pastor, King of Kings) and Zach Zehnder (Red Letter Living), connect with other church workers, and take home free, ready-to-use resources. Early-bird registration is $199 per group of up to 8 through April 30, 2027; regular pricing is $299. https://reigniteconference.com.
Resources Mentioned
Connect with Rob Bailey
- South Lake Church — League City, Texas: https://southlakelc.org/
- Email Rob: rbailey@southlakelc.org
Resources Mentioned
- 2026 State of the LCMS Survey Interactive Results — Explore survey responses, trends, and demographic comparisons.
- ChatGPT — AI platform discussed throughout the episode.
- Google NotebookLM — AI-assisted research and learning tool that organizes source materials and generates study resources.
- Claude — An alternative AI assistant discussed during the conversation.
- Logos Bible Software — Biblical study and theological research software.
- Book of Concord — Lutheran confessional writings.
- Concordia Seminary, St. Louis — Seminary where Rob received his pastoral education.
- Red Letter Challenge — Discipleship resources and ministry tools.
Additional Resource
Interested in seeing an example of Rob’s AI-assisted sermon preparation materials? Email hello@redletterchallenge.com to request an example, as discussed in the episode.
Key insights from the episode
-
- AI can help pastors prepare sermons without writing their sermons for them.
Rob shares how he uses AI to organize biblical commentaries, Greek and Hebrew resources, Lutheran theological writings, and sermon preparation materials. Rather than outsourcing the responsibility of preaching, he uses technology to deepen his engagement with Scripture throughout the week.
- Artificial intelligence can make large amounts of information more accessible.
Using the 2026 State of the LCMS Survey as an example, Rob explains how AI helped analyze 3,070 responses, identify patterns, create visualizations, and develop an interactive website. Tasks that once required complicated spreadsheets and formulas can now become more accessible through conversational questions.
- Churches need clear ethical and privacy guardrails for AI.
As AI becomes increasingly common among church staff, Rob encourages churches to establish written policies, particularly regarding confidential information, data protection, transparency, and acceptable uses of technology.
- AI can provide answers, but it cannot replace genuine pastoral relationships.
A computer may generate a compelling theological response, but it cannot replace the human experience, personal relationships, and spiritual responsibility involved in caring for others. Ministry is about more than distributing accurate information.
- The dangers of AI extend beyond inaccurate answers.
Zach and Rob discuss AI companionship, confirmation bias, misinformation, and the possibility that people could increasingly substitute artificial relationships for the challenges and rewards of genuine community.
- AI will reshape the way people work, particularly young adults.
Rob raises concerns about how automation could affect entry-level employment opportunities and professional development. Church leaders need to be prepared to encourage and support people navigating a changing workforce.
- AI can help churches develop new discipleship resources.
From interactive Bible studies to personalized educational resources, AI creates opportunities to make faithful Christian teaching more accessible. The challenge is ensuring that technology supports sound theology and genuine spiritual growth.
Are you following Jesus?
Many want to be greater followers of Jesus but don’t know how. We extensively studied everything Jesus commanded of us and located five key targets to which Jesus invited His followers. The five targets are Being, Forgiving, Serving, Giving, and Going.
In partnership with LifeWay Research, we created a Red Letter Challenge Assessment that will measure you according to these five targets. And the best news of all: it’s free! You will get results back immediately and be presented with the next steps to help you become an even greater follower of Jesus.
You can take the FREE Red Letter Challenge Assessment here.
Watch all episodes for free:
We’ll be uploading every episode of The Red Letter Disciple on our YouTube Channel. If you aren’t subscribed already, you can do so her