Dr. Todd Jones joins Zach to explore pastoral formation, ecclesiology, and the growing tension between Synod and the local church in the LCMS—drawing from C.F.W. Walther and decades of ministry experience.
Todd brings decades of experience as a pastor, church planter, district mission executive, seminary professor, and now Director of Ministry Formation at the Center for Missional and Pastoral Leadership (CMPL). Drawing deeply from C.F.W. Walther’s The Duties of an Evangelical Synod, Todd argues that many of today’s conflicts are not political—but ecclesiological.
Together, Zach and Todd explore the LCMS’s congregational roots, the rise of centralized power, prior approval, pastoral class systems, and what it means to remain faithful to Christ when institutions drift from their stated theology. This episode wrestles honestly with authority, transparency, trust, and the future of pastoral formation—while continually calling listeners back to the local church and the mission of reconciliation.
Today’s episode is brought to you by Red Letter Living. We create resources to help the church produce greater disciples.
For so many Christians (and even churches), the discipleship process isn’t very clear.
They know they need to go to church, pray, not sin, and maybe attend a small group. While these are great things, they don’t outline a clear path leading people to live more like Jesus.
We’d love to introduce you to the 40-Day Red Letter Challenge.
When you and your church take the challenge, you’ll have a clear 40-day discipleship path that will help you master five key areas of discipleship.
You can learn more about the challenge here!
“Politics isn’t the greatest threat to the LCMS—ecclesiology is.” — Todd Jones
“When Synod moves from advisory to legislative, it begins to take authority that belongs only to Christ.” — Todd Jones
“The church is not Synod. The church is the local congregation gathered around Word and Sacrament.” — Todd Jones
“Power always seeks to preserve itself. That’s why transparency matters so much.” — Todd Jones
“The work of the kingdom does not happen through systems—it happens through local congregations sharing the gospel.” — Todd Jones
Live as an ambassador of reconciliation.
Seek reconciliation where relationships are broken—or share Christ’s reconciling work with someone who does not yet know the Father’s love.
Are you following Jesus?
Many want to be greater followers of Jesus but don’t know how. We extensively studied everything Jesus commanded of us and located five key targets to which Jesus invited His followers. The five targets are Being, Forgiving, Serving, Giving, and Going.
In partnership with LifeWay Research, we created a Red Letter Challenge Assessment that will measure you according to these five targets. And the best news of all: it’s free! You will get results back immediately and be presented with the next steps to help you become an even greater follower of Jesus.
You can take the FREE Red Letter Challenge Assessment here.
0:01–6:43 — Intro & Todd’s faith journey
Todd shares his family’s journey into Lutheranism and his early passion for evangelism and church planting.
6:43–10:00 — From parish ministry to church planting
Todd reflects on planting multi-ethnic congregations and serving in revitalization contexts.
10:00–13:09 — District leadership, seminary service, and formation
How Todd’s experience shaped his understanding of pastoral formation and contextual ministry.
13:09–17:10 — What is CMPL (SIMPLE)?
Todd explains his current role and how formation is integrated into real ministry contexts.
17:10–23:02 — Why Todd began writing on ecclesiology
The influence of Walther’s The Duties of an Evangelical Synod and why it feels prophetic today.
23:02–29:56 — What is ecclesiology—and why it matters now
Hierarchical vs. congregational models and how the LCMS historically understood authority.
29:56–33:31 — Advisory vs. legislative Synod
How practices like prior approval reflect a shift away from congregational polity.
33:31–39:28 — Walther’s warnings about power and titles
Why careerism, bureaucracy, and centralized authority signal ecclesiological drift.
39:28–46:15 — Pastoral class systems & SMP realities
Data, lived experience, and the harmful impact of “second-tier” pastors.
46:15–48:09 — What to do when Synod oversteps
Walther’s call to resist faithfully—and why obedience to Christ comes first.
48:09–55:18 — Pastoral formation detached from the local church
Historical pathways into ministry and why congregations once carried real responsibility.
55:18–57:51 — When did things change?
Incremental shifts, post-walkout fear, and the rise of institutional control.
57:51–1:02:15 — A tangible path forward: equip the laity
Why congregations—not pastors alone—must reclaim their theological authority.
1:02:15–1:04:47 — Prior approval & transparency
Why secrecy undermines trust and damages brotherly accountability.
1:04:47–1:11:11 — United List, slander, and institutional fear
How unofficial power structures distort discernment and unity.
1:11:11–1:13:04 — Hope for congregations, realism about institutions
Why Todd remains hopeful for churches—even if Synod continues to devolve.
1:13:04–1:14:20 — Todd’s discipleship challenge
Be reconciled. Be reconcilers. Live as ambassadors of Christ.
1:14:20–1:15:34 — How to connect with Todd
Todd’s Substack and contact information.
We’ll be uploading every episode of The Red Letter Disciple on our YouTube Channel. If you aren’t subscribed already, you can do so her
