The pastoral formation conversation is no longer happening on the sidelines.

As the 2026 LCMS Convention approaches, nearly 90 overtures touch on pastoral formation, seminary education, SMP, alternate routes, and the future of preparing pastors for ministry.

What is driving the debate?

Why are so many pastors and church leaders concerned?

And have we been here before?

In this episode, Zach sits down with Dr. Andy Bartelt, longtime Concordia Seminary professor, former Academic Dean, and participant in many of the conversations that shaped modern pastoral formation pathways within the LCMS.

Drawing from decades of experience, Bartelt explains how the current debate emerged, why SMP was originally created, how seminary education has changed over time, and why healthy dialogue is desperately needed.

Topics include:

• Why nearly 90 overtures on pastoral formation are headed to convention
• The origins of Delta and SMP
• The tension between “getting it right” and “getting it out”
• Residential versus contextual theological education
• The strengths and weaknesses of different formation pathways
• The future role of the seminaries
• Stewardship, mission, and church growth
• Why listening may be more important than winning

 

Whether you’re a pastor, church worker, seminary student, district leader, or engaged layperson, this conversation provides important context for one of the biggest issues facing the LCMS today.

   

Today’s episode is brought to you by Hodos. Hodos is a new non-profit designed to pave the way for the next generation of Lutherans. Designed for 18-29 year olds, Hodos is currently planning a national Young Adult Gathering for 2027. For interest, updated information, or donation options, please go to www.HodosWay.com.

Resources Mentioned

Concordia Seminary St. Louis

https://www.csl.edu

Concordia Theological Seminary Fort Wayne

https://www.ctsfw.edu

LCMS Seminary Education Overview

https://www.lcms.org/how-we-serve/education/pastoral/seminary-education

HODOS Movement

https://www.hodosway.com

Andy Bartelt’s Paper

Email Andy: bartelta@csl.edu

Key insights from the episode

1. The Current Debate Didn’t Start Yesterday

Many of today’s pastoral formation discussions have been developing for decades and are rooted in long-standing questions about mission, education, and ministry.

2. SMP Was Created to Solve Multiple Problems

The program emerged not only to address pastoral shortages but also to create pathways for ministry in mission contexts and underserved communities.

3. Residential and Contextual Formation Both Have Strengths

Rather than viewing the discussion as either-or, Bartelt argues both approaches bring unique benefits and challenges.

4. The Church Must Hold Two Priorities Together

Faithfulness to doctrine and expansion of mission must remain in healthy tension.

5. Listening Is Essential

Meaningful progress requires understanding opposing viewpoints before critiquing them.

Conversation Highlights

• Why Andy Bartelt decided to enter the pastoral formation conversation
• The real story behind Delta and SMP
• What many LCMS members have forgotten about Springfield Seminary
• Why pastoral formation debates often become emotionally charged
• The difference between contextual and residential education
• The stewardship questions surrounding two seminaries
• How mission opportunities shaped alternative pathways
• What gives Bartelt a lack of hope for the future of the LCMS

Are you following Jesus? 

Many want to be greater followers of Jesus but don’t know how. We extensively studied everything Jesus commanded of us and located five key targets to which Jesus invited His followers. The five targets are Being, Forgiving, Serving, Giving, and Going.

In partnership with LifeWay Research, we created a Red Letter Challenge Assessment that will measure you according to these five targets. And the best news of all: it’s free! You will get results back immediately and be presented with the next steps to help you become an even greater follower of Jesus.

You can take the FREE Red Letter Challenge Assessment here.

Watch all episodes for free: 

We’ll be uploading every episode of The Red Letter Disciple on our YouTube Channel. If you aren’t subscribed already, you can do so here.