Pastoral formation is one of the most important and most debated topics in the LCMS today.

In this episode, Zach sits down with two district presidents, Rev. Dr. Nathan Meador (South Wisconsin District) and Rev. Wally Vinovskis (SELC District), for a candid, respectful, and deeply pastoral conversation about how we form pastors for the future.

This isn’t a shouting match. It’s a real conversation.

Together, they explore:

• What churches are actually looking for in a pastor today
• The non-negotiables of pastoral formation
• The strengths and risks of both residential and online (SMP) seminary pathways
• The growing tension between doctrinal faithfulness and mission urgency
• Why relationships, mentorship, and real-life ministry context matter
• How we can disagree without dividing

At the heart of it all is one question: How do we form pastors who are faithful, relational, and ready to shepherd real people?

If you care about the future of the church, pastoral leadership, or theological education, then lean in, because this conversation matters.

Today’s episode is brought to you by Hodos. Hodos is a new non-profit designed to pave the way for the next generation of Lutherans. Designed for 18-29 year olds, Hodos is currently planning a national Young Adult Gathering for 2027. For interest, updated information, or donation options, please go to www.HodosWay.com.

Resources Mentioned

LCMS Seminary (St. Louis)
https://www.csl.edu/

Concordia Theological Seminary (Fort Wayne)
https://www.ctsfw.edu/

SMP Program Overview
https://www.csl.edu/academics/programs/specific-ministry-pastor-smp/

The Hammer of God (Bo Giertz)
https://www.amazon.com/Hammer-God-Bo-Giertz/dp/0806621312

Walther’s Law & Gospel
https://www.cph.org/law-and-gospel

Key insights from the episode

Churches aren’t looking for perfect pastors. They’re looking for faithful witnesses who know their people.

The most important non-negotiable?
“Don’t be a jerk.” (Seriously.)

Pastoral formation must include both:

• Theological depth
• Relational maturity

Residential seminary provides:

• Broad exposure
• Deep theological training including the original languages
• Formation through a shared community

Online/SMP pathways provide:

• Flexibility
• Contextual training
• Solutions for real ministry gaps
• Meeting needs of churches and/or communities

The real tension:

• Under-formed pastors vs. unreached people

The biggest danger amongst current pastors isn’t disagreement. It’s refusing to talk to each other.

Healthy church culture requires:

• Conversation
• Brotherhood
• Trust in Christ at the center

Conversation Highlights

What churches actually want in a pastor (Acts 1 model)

The four types of churches calling pastors today

Why “handling the Word” still matters deeply

Greek, Hebrew, and real preaching (not just theory)

Why mentorship is critical in pastoral formation

The danger of “filling pulpits” instead of forming pastors

The emotional reality: churches begging for pastors

Why online debates feel toxic—but in-person conversations don’t

The risk of isolation vs. the risk of inflexibility

SMP vs. placement

Why pastors must remain brothers—even in disagreement

Guest’s Challenge of the Week

Find the pastor you disagree with most and have coffee or lunch with him. Don’t cancel. Don’t label. Talk. Listen. Stay brothers.

Are you following Jesus? 

Many want to be greater followers of Jesus but don’t know how. We extensively studied everything Jesus commanded of us and located five key targets to which Jesus invited His followers. The five targets are Being, Forgiving, Serving, Giving, and Going.

In partnership with LifeWay Research, we created a Red Letter Challenge Assessment that will measure you according to these five targets. And the best news of all: it’s free! You will get results back immediately and be presented with the next steps to help you become an even greater follower of Jesus.

You can take the FREE Red Letter Challenge Assessment here.